Laurence Olivier Awards Best New Musical Best Actor in a Musical	London, 1990 1990, 2000
Tony Awards Best Actor in a Musical	New York, 1991
Outer Circle Awards Best New Musical Best Performance in a Musical	New York, 1991
Drama Desk Awards Outstanding Actor in a Musical	New York, 1991
Theatre World Awards Outstanding Debut Performance	New York, 1991
Dora Mavor Moore Awards Outstanding Production Outstanding Musical Direction Outstanding Performance Outstanding Set Design Outstanding Costume Design	Toronto, 1991
Manchester Evening News Best Actor in a Musical Best Touring Musical	United Kingdom, 1992
Helen Hayes Awards Best Touring Production Best Actor in a Touring Production Best Actor in a Resident Musical	Washington DC, 1993 2007
Australian Entertainment Mo Awards Best Theatrical Production	Australia, 1993
DALRO Awards Best Performance in a Foreign Production	South Africa, 1994
Vita Awards Best Musical Theatre Production Best Performance in a Musical	South Africa, 1994
Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle Awards Best Musical Best Ensemble Best Actor in a Musical	San Francisco, 2004
What’s On Stage Theatregoers’ Choice Awards Best Musical Revival	London, 2008
Suzi Bass Awards Lead Actor in a Musical	Atlanta, 2009
The Sterlings Outstanding Production of a Musical Outstanding Musical Director Outstanding Choreography	Edmonton, 2010
Jessie Richardson Theatre Awards Outstanding Actor in a Lead Role	Vancouver, 2010
San Diego Theatre Critics Circle Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical	San Diego, 2017
Joseph Jefferson Awards Best Production, Musical (Midsize) Best Director (Midsize Theater) Best Ensemble, Musical Best Performer in a Principal Role, Musical Best Music Direction	Chicago, 2018 2018, 2023